Da Reviews Thread

[Necros]

pack:   

[gnr61]

i will post reviews D:

[Lain]

smooooch: best song ever bye

[Kil]

your opinions wrong

[Lain]

your pop'n song choices wrong

[Kil]

no they arent

[Lain]

well your gay

[Kil]

no im not

[Kommisar]

you're all gay go play the pack

[Lain]

sry it's still downloading and i'm just making idle banter with kil i'll stop shitting up this thread and make real reviews later

[GLoVE]

Guns&Roses - i forgot what keys i had mapped so i failed 0/10

Fuurin - all the minijacks obviously arent accurate but it works. solid file i liked it but i was kinda busy trying to play the game. 8/10

The Torurous Marionette's Melody - rly cool file 8/10

the least 100sec - omfg it owwwwwwns 10/10

cross time - fun but some parts shouldve been done better and i feel like there were a bunch of pretty important notes missing but good patterns and good scoring file 6.5/10

oriental inspiration - boring and didnt fit the song even though it mightve been accurate 4/10

i have more 2 cum

[Squeesfan]

packs still downloading, but from stuff I had before:

skeletones: awesome file with cool slow downs bpm tricks etc. nothing hugely new but nothing wrong, so 7/10.

six: sweet file, really hard on index, decent on spread. some cool patterns although i hated a couple of others. 7/10

marionette melody: fun file, but i dunno if i would play thaaat much 7.5/10

the biggest band: awesome. 8/10

Max Love: mines were cool, I still play this quite alot as a warm up song: 7.5/10

[SkySeal]

open your mind: some parts are understepped and some parts are overstepped but that was really fun
over the ocean: its better than malice's except for the chorus
divine service: gr8 song, chart starts off a little understepped but in the end its great
the least 100 sec: consistent and fun
drive blare or whatever its called: jimerax rules

got tired so w/e

[aCiiiii]

uhh how can i put this...

this pack revived sm

[codcrille]

This pack killed sm for a year and then revived it.

[notlurker]

This pack killed sm for a year and then revived it.

this is most likely the best way to describe it
i hope you all learned a fucking lesson from this
the stepmania community at this point is too lazy to make an unreleased pack (although the rf site going down most likely played a considerable role in how long it took), so the next major one should probably be mostly previously-released files like the odi packs or something
also, DON'T WAIT UNTIL THE VERY END TO GET SHIT DONE HOLY FUCK

[Dj_Ossa]

I'll play this tomorrow.

[Lain]

assorted files i played:


banbutsu kairaku riron: okay file, nothing particularly spectacular about it. 6/10

cities of the future: solid file, really fun middle part, kind of disappointing ending though. 8/10

cockpit: pretty generic file, jimmy weckl is cool. 6/10

cosmic orchestra: solid file, fun to play. 7/10

cross time: only played oni, was not that great. didn't catch a lot of climax moments properly that I thought would be caught. i'll be sticking with laggy's or even minion's. 4/10

drove through ghosts to get here: badass song, kind of a dumpy file with way, way too many quads. disappointing. 5/10

epileptic crisis: awesome song, awesome file, both difficulties are good, very challenging, a bit dumpy on heavy though. 8/10

ergosphere: tomosuke pianers, nothing special. 6/10

fuurin: oh yeah baby, i like it when you minijack all over my tits. 8/10

guns & roses: actually pretty fun and a cool song. 8/10

infinity: vocaloid is ass and this file is too long. 5/10

negative nature: good file, again, nothing particularly special about it besides it not having a lot of errors. 6/10

oriental inspiration: generic oster project. 5/10

over the ocean: play malice's simfile that was released in PPP2. you'll thank me later. 5/10

skeletones: i like macgravel and if you don't like macgravel you don't like america and if you don't like america you can get out. glitchcraft was better than this, but still a good file albeit a little strange for this pack. 7/10

smooooch: heavy is better than oni for some reason. kind of a disappointing file, still an infectious song. 6/10

SURVIVOR: offbeat or something, other than that...it was okay. 6/10

taking back my soul: i love you glove. i don't want to give perfect ratings but holy shit dude. definitely my favorite file in the pack so far. 9/10

the least 100 sec: solid file with good progression, good difficulty. 7/10

the torturous marionette's melody: enjoyable file, cool song, malice likes quads. 7/10

tripping contact: i've played way better tripping contacts than this, this one is pretty bad. 4/10

valkyrja: good file, a little easy and a little repetitive. 6/10



yep.

[Kil]

wrong

[Lain]

just shut up idiot.. this is not a topic to dumb around..